Dr Matt Shelton’s HPDT Hearing: Evidence, Expert Witnesses and What Comes Next

The following is a measured and somewhat legally restricted description. Dr Shelton’s case has waited a long time but we must be temperate whilst the process is still active. It is unknown when the judgement will be released.
Dr Matt Shelton’s proceedings before the Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal (HPDT) concluded recently in Wellington. He was first contacted by the Medical Council of New Zealand (MCNZ) in August 2021 about his professional conduct after he sent a text message to his patients alerting them to his concerns about the lack of safety data for covid vaccines especially for pregnant women and children. He advised them to make a considered rather than rushed or coerced decision. It got to the newspapers and within days his GP business was taken from him and he was ejected from the College of GPs.
His Annual Practicing Certificate (APC) was suspended after 3 months of unsuccessfully trying to negotiate a suitable “Voluntary Undertaking” about keeping his concerns to himself. He then appealed the suspension in the District Court in March 2022 and it was overturned. Despite this, the MCNZ threatened to re-suspend his APC if he applied for a new one.
Eventually the MCNZ convened a Professional Conduct Committee (PCC) process in late 2022. The PCC was provided with or ‘came across’ further statements from Dr Shelton – all made before his District Court appeal and already heard by the Court – that ran counter to the official government narrative. His speeches and interviews related to repurposed treatments for covid-19, vaccine safety and efficacy, and concerns re magnetism and contents of the vaccine vials, including whether there were undeclared ingredients and/or contamination in them. Following their deliberations the PCC referred him to the HPDT. It has taken several years for this Tribunal to finally sit and hear the charges.
Of note, the Health and Disability Commission (HDC) carried out its own investigation and found that Dr Shelton had improperly used his practice’s text message system to communicate with his patients and had (curiously) violated clause 6 of the HDC code – the right of his patients to receive information a reasonable health consumer would expect!
The hearing commenced on 30 September 2026 and concluded on 14 October 2026. The charges relate to six videos posted online between May 2021 and March 2022, and a Facebook post. The charges have a number of particulars that appear to relate to statements Dr Shelton made that the MCNZ’s PCC has deemed to be ‘inaccurate’, ‘misleading’, or ‘inappropriate’, possibly also ‘unbalanced’. The details of the particular statements are not entirely clear.
Dr Shelton gave his evidence for a day and was cross examined for nearly a further two. At the end, the Chair commended him for having conducted himself so well ‘for so long and in such a measured way’. His own lawyer noted ‘I don’t think I have ever seen a practitioner give evidence for such a long period of time’.
One of us was granted permission to take notes and this is what the following account is taken from. Dr Shelton is bound by court rules preventing him from saying anything that might be seen to influence the tribunal’s search for the truth. His evidence was very powerful, outlining the journey that had got him to the point where he felt a fiduciary obligation to New Zealanders to make the statements he did. It demonstrated his search for answers to reasonable questions that was continually stonewalled and his subsequent deep concern for the population of New Zealand as he witnessed increasing reports of harm. The scope of his evidence covered much of what NZDSOS has been engaged with over subsequent years. When he finished giving his evidence, despite the strict instruction from the Chair to be quiet, observe and not participate, the audience couldn’t help but burst out into muted applause.
The two days of cross examination by the PCC’s lawyers were repetitive and much of it was “Would you agree that (whatever statement) was inaccurate, misleading or inappropriate?” Dr Shelton tried hard to explain the science and evidence that backed up his statements and his concerns.
Witnesses for the Professional Conduct Committee (PCC)
The two witnesses for the PCC were Dr Nikki Turner (NZ GP, vaccinologist and medical director of IMAC) and Dr Janine Paynter (scientist at Auckland University).
Dr Turner presented her evidence and then was cross- examined for just over a day. Her potential conflicts of interests were drawn out – medical advisor to IMAC (charged with promoting immunisation), involved with writing the Immunisation Handbook (interestingly the chapter on covid vaccines was being drafted in late 2020 well before the Pfizer vaccine had approval in NZ), being on multiple national advisory groups and a member of a WHO strategic advisory group. Dr Turner made a number of interesting points which gave us pause.
Dr Paynter was up next and spoke about the scientific method, ‘reputable science’ and the peer review process. A number of comments regarding mis- and disinformation made it into Dr Paynter’s evidence, despite an earlier comment from the tribunal that such pejorative labels were unhelpful. She said that NZDSOS, Voices for Freedom and Counterspin Media were purveyors of misinformation. This was challenged and removed from consideration. Of note, Hannah Spierer of Counterspin was subsequently given permission to take notes.
Witnesses for Dr Matt Shelton
James Allen, law professor and witness for Dr Shelton spoke about Informed Consent and how it is fundamental to medical practice, and also about the Bill of Rights and Human Rights. He described his disillusionment with his own profession during covid with very few lawyers prepared to defend basic rights. He noted he had also become disillusioned with and disappointed by the medical profession which once he held in high regard.
Dr Phillip Altman (Australian pharmacologist with 40 yrs in drug approval) provided measured but powerful evidence that normal processes had not been followed in the development of the Pfizer vaccine and that the data relied on for approval was inadequate. He reiterated much of Dr Shelton’s evidence that it wasn’t a ‘vaccine’ and fitted prior definitions of gene therapy before definitions were changed. He noted that the product tested in the clinical trial manufactured by Process 1 was not the same as the one mass produced for population wide use. He pointed to the presence of potentially carcinogenic Simian Virus 40 (SV40) gene code in the product produced by Process 2.
Dr Altman also expressed deep misgivings about the pharmacovigilance being undertaken noting that it is all very well to collect and collate data about adverse events, but the data also needs to be analysed. His expectation would be that reports to CARM would have further information including medical records from the affected person gathered and causality assessments using recognised frameworks such as Bradford Hill undertaken. He also provided evidence for the known benefits and benign toxicity profile of ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine.
In the second week Prof. Angus Dalgleish gave testimony on Monday. He covered a lot of territory, drawing on his expertise in viral immunology, vaccine development and as a cancer specialist. He described the refusal of medical journals to publish his and others’ important covid papers, being told they were “not in the public interest”.
On Tuesday Dr Pierre Kory gave evidence and was cross examined. A credentialed expert in intensive care until losing his board certification for his advocacy for treating covid early in the infection, he has become an acknowledged expert on ivermectin and the evidence for it. He described the cherry-picking of trials and fraud to discredit repurposed treatments. Echoing Professor Dalgleish he described being told a major review paper he tried to submit was not likely to engage reader interest. Both spoke to the loss of faith in medical journal independence.
Other witnesses who appeared included Dr Monica Clark-Grill, a long-time GP and bioethicist. She had little truck with the new collectivist (greater good) approach to medical ethics and described the fundamental ethical duty of honesty which public health doctors have when addressing the population.
There were three witnesses to their own or others’ magnetism, discovered post vaccine. Closing submissions for each side will be provided to the HPDT, then their public discussion heard around the 12th of December, likely by audio-visual link.
It may then be many months before Dr Shelton hears the outcome of the Tribunal.
Good on you Dr Matt Sheldon you are a true doctor who cares and lives by the oath.
Stand strong truth always comes through.
They will try to financially ruin you just as they tried with another hero of the people Dr Sam Bailey.
What the medical council did was disgusting and untruthful, politically bent out of shape.
Good luck for the future it will be bright, get your dark glasses ready.
Kind regards
Peter Barnett
What part of the MCNZ agreement or the law do the MCNZ falsely claim Matt breached by telling a patient( or a non patient by txt accidently ) to use “due diligence” ?
ie what was their false claim?
And did Matt use a solicitor( Crown law society ) to represent him?
I dont understand why Matt would agree to appear at the MCNZ witch hunt- show trial tribunal giving them the right to decide the claim
probably done to put men and woman off being real physicians .
They had no authority or jurisdiction over you except what you give them (by coercion or signature).
If you had used Christine Massey’s already established reasonable doubt of ” covid19″ it would be more effective and productive defense.
As the Crown NZ Govt( MCNZ and HDC) they had no proof of any new dis-ease.
Whole things a redirection from a multi billion dollar criminal fraud( convid19).
Where are the stiff back bones of the 1946 Nuremberg Trials…..as a teenager I learnt these fundamentals and the question is have the mad scientists taken control of the world?
The Medical Council should hang their head in shame, be fired and prosecuted along with Ardern, Hipkins, Verral, Bloomfield and the 11,000 that quietly gave themselves exemptions.
Lest we Forget…..too late!!!